The found footage genre has always walked a fine line between brilliance and gimmick—but every so often, a film comes along that reminds us of its potential. Man Finds Tape is one of those films. Eerie, immersive, and quietly unsettling, it breathes new life into a format that thrives on ambiguity. It asks a chilling question: what if the monsters of today aren’t hiding in the shadows, but standing right in front of us?

The story follows siblings Lynn (Kelsey Pribilski) and Lucas Page (William Magnuson), whose fragmented recollections of recent events in the town of Larkin, Texas, paint a disturbing picture. After Lucas begins suffering blackouts and memory loss tied to his investigation into their parents’ mysterious illness and death, Lynn picks up the trail, determined to piece together what really happened.

Presented as a pseudo-documentary, the film blends various media—interviews, 911 call audio, Reddit threads, grainy secret footage, and a town-shaking hit-and-run—creating an eerie sense of realism. Each layer adds to the mystery, building a web of paranoia and dread that tightens with every revelation. The deeper we dig, the clearer it becomes: this isn’t just a ghost story. It’s a warning.

At the heart of the mystery lies Reverend Endicott Carr (John Gholson), a figure deeply embedded in the town’s social fabric—and perhaps at the center of its darkest secrets. His ties to Lucas’ girlfriend, Wendy Parker (Nell Kessler), only deepen the web of suspicion. But just when you think you’ve figured it out, directors Peter Hall and Paul Gandersman introduce a wildcard: the Stranger (Brian Villalobos), a haunting figure reminiscent of Stephen King’s Man in Black from The Dark Tower.

What follows is a gripping and satisfying descent into paranoia, complete with practical effects and a final reveal that is truly horrifying. Man Finds Tape plays with internet conspiracy culture, collective hysteria, and the fear of the unseen in ways that evoke both Slither and The X-Files. The audience becomes an active participant in the investigation, combing through clues alongside the characters—an element that makes the experience feel all the more immersive and unnerving.

What could have been just another standard found footage film becomes one of the most surprising and inventive entries in the genre in recent years. It’s a smart, scary, and surprisingly emotional story that lingers long after the credits roll.

3.5 Seth’s out of 5